Simone Biles’ shock exit sparks discourse on mental health

by Odelia Tham

Star gymnast and GOAT (greatest of all time) Simone Biles, pulled out of the Women’s gymnastics final in Tokyo due to mental health concerns after baulking her first attempt on the vault on Tuesday night.

Bile’s decision to withdraw from the competition reveals the toxic culture of the Olympic games, as looming expectations and hard-hitting pressures continue to harrow athletes.

Biles, who won gold on the vault in Rio 2016, has been known to tackle precarious moves that no other female gymnasts dare to attempt, especially when she became the first woman to land a Yurchenko double pike at US Classics earlier this year.

Unfortunately, the four-time gold medallist, who is likened to perfection, completed only 1.5 rotations instead of 2.5 in her first vault on Tuesday. Her hesitation and expectations, melded with the pressure-cooker environment of the Games resulted in a jarringly shaky performance that shocked the world.

With a history of national and international championship domination, and five Olympic medals at the mere age of 24, it’s no wonder people were stunned when the GOAT stepped down for the sake of her team, and her health.

“It’s OK sometimes to even sit out the big competitions to focus on yourself because it shows how strong of a competitor and person that you really are,” Biles explained to the media after USA took home silver in the finals.

“I just felt like it would be a little bit better to take a back seat, work on my mindfulness and I knew that the girls would do an absolutely great job and I didn’t want to risk the team a medal for my screw ups because they worked too hard for that.”

The team’s defeat to the ROC on Tuesday marked the first time the USA had lost a gymnastics team final in an Olympics or a world championship since 2010.

In a social media post, Biles credited her poor performance to the immense pressure created by the Olympics.

A post from Simone Biles explaining the situation.

“I truly do feel like I have the weight of the world on my shoulders at times,” she wrote.

She elaborated on those comments when she faced the media in Tokyo, saying that the pressure of expectations remains heavy.

“There were a couple of days when everybody tweets you and you feel the weight of the world,” Biles said.

“We’re not just athletes, we’re people at the end of the day, and sometimes you just have to step back.”

With pressure weighing on her, what Biles experienced may have been a clear case of the ‘twisties’, a mysterious phenomenon coined by the gymnastics subculture. It is used to describe a kind of mental block where a gymnast is no longer able to do a twisting skill she’s done thousands of times before because both her mind and body fail to cooperate in the air.

British gymnast Claudia Fragapane and former gymnast Christina Myers have expressed their compassion for Biles to the BBC, as they have also experienced the notorious mental freeze.

Fans and supporters, amongst other influential names, have rallied around Biles after her exit.

Tweet from best-selling author, Jamie Tworkowski

“Athletes are human. Let’s normalize prioritizing mental health over performance. Let’s live in a world where you job comes second to your well-being,” New York Times best-selling author, Jamie Tworkowski, tweeted.

Michelle Obama also rooted for Biles when she tweeted her pride and support for the athlete.

Former Olympian and winner of 28 medals, Michael Phelps, told NBC Philedelphia that although the news broke his heart, mental health has been an emerging topic over the last 18 months.

“We’re human beings. Nobody is perfect. It is okay to not be okay. It is okay to go through ups and downs and emotion roller coasters. But I think the biggest thing is we all need to ask for help sometimes, too, when we go through those times,” Phelps said.

However, Biles’ decision is not without some controversy.

Piers Morgan, former British TV show host, jumped at the first chance to criticise Biles.

“Are ‘mental health issues’ now the go-to excuse for any poor performance in elite sport? What a joke,” he tweeted.

Conservative writer Amber Athey labelled Biles a “quitter” while podcaster Charlie Kirk called her a “selfish sociopath” and a “shame to the country”.

Earlier this year, we’ve seen other athletes step away from competition for nonphysical reasons before Simone Biles.

Young Black athletes are now, more than ever, setting the stage to revolutionize mental health.

Olympic gold medal-winning swimmer Simone Manuel spoke openly about taking a break after being diagnosed with overtraining syndrome earlier this year. Tennis star and four-time Grand Slam tournament winner Naomi Osaka withdrew from the 2021 French Open Tournament and Wimbledon in June, citing mental health reasons. In July, Sha’Carri Richardson, winner of women’s 100m race at Olympic Trials, was banned from the games after testing positive for marijuana, which she admittedly used to cope with the death of her biological mother.

Biles is part of a generation of elite Black athletes who have taken their mental health into their own hands and are not afraid to speak openly about their struggles.

While we have not necessarily seen these athletes at their best, we have indeed seen them at their truest.

As Australian gymnast Mary-Anne Monkton told The Age and Sydney Morning Herald, these athletes are collectively “sending a message to the world that it’s OK not to be OK.″

Check Also

Students express concerns over corporatisation of Mardi Gras

UNSW’s Queer Collective has echoed LGBTQIA+ activists’ concerns about the increasing ‘corporatisation’ of Sydney’s Mardi Gras Parade. For the second consecutive year, the parade has moved from its historic home along Oxford Street to the Sydney Cricket Ground (SCG).